I've been doing a lot of articles about action movies lately, so I think it's time we shift gears and look at something a bit different. It's the Holiday season, and that's the time of year when lots of things start happening. It's that time when stores become battlefields, the shows you actually want to watch get taken off the air in favor of whatever cheap Christmas specials their networks can get the rights to, and blizzards come in to make sure you can't leave your house. Naturally, it makes sense to discuss a holiday film, and there are many great classics. It's a Wonderful Life is a great movie, and maybe this year I'll finally get to see White Christmas with Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye.
Still,
Christmas movies can be a bit formulaic. They're generally very upbeat,
light-hearted films. Some might be heavier than others but in most cases things
turn out okay in the end. They're also in most cases family films. Perhaps
you're a bit sick of this kind of thing. Far too many movies to count approach
Christmas in the form of a quirky comedy or a light-hearted drama about family
relations. We need something different, and there are a handful of movies that
deliver. The Lion in Winter is a Christmas movie that centers around several
characters, most of them members of the British Royal Family, scheming against
each other and stabbing each other in the back. Die Hard is an action movie
that happens to take place around Christmas. You could also read H.P.
Lovecraft's The Festival if you like your Christmas stories with a dash of cosmic
horror.
But perhaps
that's not good enough for you. Maybe we need something more adult, more sexual
in nature. Well it should only make sense for such a film to be made by one of
the greatest directors who ever lived, Stanley Kubrick. Working from a novella
titled Traumnovelle, Kubrick made quite possibly one of the strangest and most
arousing Christmas films ever conceived by a human being. It is a bizarre film
to say the least, with sexual themes, scenes filled to the brim with nudity, a
haunting orgy sequence, and Tom Cruise actually displaying some talent as an
actor. The result was his final movie, Eyes Wide Shut.
I suspect
there may be some influence from David Lynch on this film. Kubrick and Lynch
had something of a mutual respect for each other's work. Lynch has on multiple
times voiced his admiration for Kubrick's work, particularly Lolita, though
that was probably not the only film that influenced him (it doesn't seem too
far-fetched to assume Lynch borrowed some ideas from A Clockwork Orange when he
was making Blue Velvet). Likewise, Lynch has an anecdote in his biography
Catching the Big Fish where he mentions an incident that happened while he was
making The Elephant Man.
According to
Lynch, he was approached by a couple of men who had recently met Kubrick, and
were invited to his house to see his "favorite film". Lynch was
naturally excited when he learned that Kubrick's favorite film turned out to be
Eraserhead. Eyes Wide Shut certainly has that dream-like atmosphere that
characterizes Lynch's movies, and even some similar ideas to Blue Velvet in the
idea of a seemingly ideal world that is revealed to have a hidden darker side.
Really, it's a shame the two of them never actually met, since a collaboration
between Stanley Kubrick and David Lynch could have been amazing.
I have this
cynical theory that true love is impossible. "Love" is just something
we constructed to give ourselves hope in our miserable lives. There is no such
thing as "love" in any sense, or is there? What does it mean to be in
love? Is it merely a matter of sexual interest, or is it something far more?
These questions are raised in Eyes Wide Shut, and it seems to very much
personify my own theory.
William "Bill" Harford (Tom Cruise) is a doctor in New York, married to a former art museum curator named Alice (Nicole Kidman) and together they've had a daughter, Helena (Madison Eginton). They claim to love each other, but from the opening scene it already seems that there is a certain strain in their relationship. In the movies, marriage is often depicted as a romantic and glamorous experience, complete with a "happily ever after". Well, here we get to see the aftermath of that "happy ending", which turns out to be very mundane.
The first
time we see Alice (not including the opening shot of her taking off her
clothes) is when she's sitting on the toilet and presumably defecating. Most
Hollywood films would skip this part, and generally they tend to stay out of
the bathroom unless it's essential to the plot. The audience is ordinarily
expected to infer that the characters occasionally have to relieve their bowels
but just do it off-screen in between key moments of the film. Stanley
Kubrick was not like other Hollywood filmmakers, and instead decides to show us
this moment in great detail. It doesn't even affect the story, Alice sitting on
the toilet is just one of many things that happen in this scene, but the fact
that Kubrick shows her seated, as well as wiping her anus and washing her hands
helps to show just how dull their relationship can be.
At the party,
the relationship between Bill and Alice is further brought into question. They
claim to be happy together, but already some of their sexual urges are coming
around. Alice gets roped into a dance with an elegantly dressed but seemingly
perverted Hungarian. From the moment he drinks from her glass it is clear that
this man has nothing but sex on his mind. Meanwhile Bill gets called upstairs
after an emergency. It seems that his friend Dr. Ziegler (Sydney Pollack) has
been sneaking off from the party to have sex with a local prostitute in the
bathroom. We even see him desperately tryingto put his pants back on as fast as he can .
Said prostitute, who we learn is named Mandy (Julienne Davis), took a
"speedball" (a mixture of heroine with cocaine) and overdosed. Bill
is able to save her, and tries to encourage her to stop taking drugs.
Back at the party,
Bill sees his wife dancing with another man. Later the two of them begin having
sex, ironically while smoking pot despite the events of the previous scene.
What starts off as a romantic moment quickly erupts into a confusing argument
in which neither side is thinking straight and aren't entirely sure what
they're disputing. Things get heated and it leads to Alice confessing that she
has experienced sexual fantasies about a guy she saw at a hotel this one time.
This begins a recurring image throughout the rest of the movie, in which Bill
is haunted by images of what his wife's fantasies might look like. As the story
progresses these images become more explicit, with the man gradually stripping
his clothes and climbing on top of Alice.
The tension
is somewhat mediated when they are interrupted by a phone call and Bill is
informed that one of his patients has just died. He goes to his house and meets
the patient's daughter, who is waiting for her boyfriend. She is understandably
grief-stricken and not thinking entirely straight, which leads to her acting on
her own sexual impulses. Bill tries to resist, and leaves when her boyfriend
arrives, but he is affected by the experience. His sexual urges are getting out
of control, and he finds himself desiring some form of experience. It doesn't
even need to be with his wife, in fact because of how haunted he is by her
confession perhaps he'd rather it not be. He simply tries to find something.
At this point, it starts to become clear that Bill's sexual urges aren't something he can control. They aren't so much a conscious decision on his part as they are instinct, human nature. He has no control over his own body's desires. He isn't driven by any form of love or even attraction to other women. He is simply driven by a biological process.
At this point, it starts to become clear that Bill's sexual urges aren't something he can control. They aren't so much a conscious decision on his part as they are instinct, human nature. He has no control over his own body's desires. He isn't driven by any form of love or even attraction to other women. He is simply driven by a biological process.
Enter Domino,
a prostitute who intercepts and seduces the vulnerable Bill on the streets. She
provides a means to satisfy Bill's urges, inviting him into her apartment for
sex. He almost goes through with it as well, agreeing to a very large fee. The
two of them begin to kiss before he gets a phone call from his wife. He assures
her that everything is fine and has a moment of realization, breaking off the
encounter with Domino but showing his appreciation for her efforts by paying
her anyway.
Bill then
encounters his old friend Nick Nightingale from medical school, now working as
a pianist. He arrives at a club where Nick was performing just in time to see
the band finish their set, but spends some time with his friend. The two take
some time to catch up before Nick gets pulled away to a mysterious gig.
According to him it always happens at 2:00 A.M. in a different location, and he
has to play blindfolded. Nick also mentions that the last time he played the
blindfold wasn't put on properly and he glimpsed something really strange. Bill
finds himself interested in this party, but also learns that everyone who
attends is costumed and masked, so he has to find one.
To accomplish
this end, Bill visits Rainbow Costumes, run by Mr. Milich (Rade Serbedzija), a
totally unsuspicious businessman who is most definitely not involved with any
shady business operations. Milich agrees to find Bill a costume and mask in
exchange for a higher than normal fee, but they are disrupted by another
strange encounter. It seems Milich's daughter (Leelee Sobieski) invited two Japanese businessmen
over for sex. She is every bit as sexually active as Bill is, possibly even more. Milich begins yelling at the two men, telling them that they will have to
answer to the police. Meanwhile, his daughter is displaying a curious
attraction towards Bill as she hides behind him, to the point where they almost
look like they are about to kiss. This is especially curious given she is
clearly underage, though the businessmen insist that she invited them which raises
a few odd questions.
Now that he
has the mask and a costume, Bill can attend to the party. Having learned the
password from Nick he is able to get through the gate and arrives at a large
mansion only to find something really odd. What we have is a haunting sequence
involving a bizarre sex-themed masquerade party. Bill puts on his mask and
begins wandering around, and witnesses some kind of ritualistic event in
progress.
The
"party", if you can call it that, includes a man in a mask and a red
cloak walking in a circle, surrounded by naked women in masks. They then
proceed to kiss each other, providing a somewhat twisted demonstration of how
men are aroused by seeing two women have sex. At this party, it seems anyone
can have sex with anybody, anonymously. It's very ritualistic, and almost feels
like some sort of cult. They even have the mysterious red-cloaked figure
chanting something in another language, possibly Latin.
The fact that
every single person is masked, right down to the guy that takes Bill's coat,
makes this part especially unnerving. With two exceptions, we never learn the
true identities of any of the men and women behind the masks (though it's
hinted that many of them are people of power who would not want to be seen in
such an environment). We hear the voices of characters but their faces remain
static. Some of them remain blank, others have disturbing expressions (there's
one guy who looks like he's screaming). Either way, the inability of the actors
to express themselves visually makes it harder to tell anyone's motives.
Bill's
presence manages to draw the attention of one couple, a man with a mask
designed with a tricorn hat, and a woman wearing a jester's mask. We never find
out for certain who these people are. We never even hear them speak, and with
the masks it is impossible to discern their expressions. What is clear is that
they have seen Bill, and acknowledge him silently with a simple nod. There is
one possibility of who one of them might be, but I have a different idea about
where he fits in. We'll discuss that in more detail later.
At this
party, Bill witnesses sex in progress. We never learn quite how it operates,
but appears to be based on a group of female participants selecting men with
whom to engage in sexual intercourse. Whether the people at the party take
turns or simply enjoy watching people have sex is not clear. All that seems to
be clear is that intercourse with anyone is fair game (Frank Booth and Alex
DeLarge would enjoy this). The whole thing seems rather alien, otherworldly
even.
Any
uneasiness the audience might be feeling upon witnessing this ritual seems to
be enforced when a mysterious woman tries to stop Bill from participating. She
keeps telling him it is dangerous and he needs to get out, but refuses to say
way. From what she describes, these people don't take kindly to uninvited
guests. At one point Bill even tries to remove her mask, which she refuses to
let him do, almost as if it is considered a crime to expose your face in the
house.
Finally, Bill
is confronted by a servant who claims the driver of his taxi wants to see him,
but instead of being led to the gate he is brought back into the large room and
confronted by the red-cloaked man (because he does not have a name, I shall
identify him as the "Inquisitor" for the purposes of this article).
The Inquisitor asks Bill for the password, but claims there is a second one
which Bill was not told about. Bill is then told to remove his mask,
exposing him to the intimidating crowd. The fact that he remains the only
character in this entire sequence whose face is seen in the mansion makes him
feel more like an outsider.
The
Inquisitor delivers a speech that seems to imply he has something horrifying in
mind for Bill. It's suggested that Bill may have ended up dead, but he is told oddly enough to "take off his clothes". It almost seems that forced sex was part of the plan. In other words, from what Bill is told, it sounds as though the Inquisitor intended him to be raped. Considering Bill has been searching for some form of "sexual encounter", the Inquisitor could therefore be seen as technically granting his wish in the form of an ironic punishment for intruding on the party.
Before any kind of forced intercourse can happen, the woman who tried to warn Bill stands up and claims herself as a "sacrifice". Precisely how this works is not clear, though from what is described it sounds as though she will die. Bill is released, although not without warning to keep quiet about everything he has seen and experienced. It's hard to tell whether the threats are genuine or purely psychological, but either way it is disturbing. Bill is finally able to leave, and returns home. He finds his wife asleep, and laughing. When she wakes up she claims that she actually had a nightmare in which she had sex with a number of men while Bill was watching.
Before any kind of forced intercourse can happen, the woman who tried to warn Bill stands up and claims herself as a "sacrifice". Precisely how this works is not clear, though from what is described it sounds as though she will die. Bill is released, although not without warning to keep quiet about everything he has seen and experienced. It's hard to tell whether the threats are genuine or purely psychological, but either way it is disturbing. Bill is finally able to leave, and returns home. He finds his wife asleep, and laughing. When she wakes up she claims that she actually had a nightmare in which she had sex with a number of men while Bill was watching.
The next day,
the first thing Bill does is find Nick's hotel, and arrives only to learn that
his friend has checked out. According to the clerk, Nick was scared, and being
escorted by two very large men. He tried to pass the clerk an envelope but it
was intercepted. The obvious implication is that Nick was killed to prevent him
from talking about the party.
His next stop
is the costume shop, where he tries to return the costume. Strangely enough,
the mask seems to have been misplaced, though Milich agrees to put it on Bill's
tab. His daughter emerges, with both the Japanese businessmen, who seem to
suddenly be on good terms with Milich. Bill is confused, as is the audience, based
on Milich's reaction to their presence when we first saw him. He claims that
"other arrangements" were made, ones that apparently involved him
selling his own daughter into prostitution. He shows no remorse for allowing a minor to be treated this way, and even offers Bill "other
services" besides costumes, which is implied to include sex with his
daughter.
Bill then
decides to visit Domino's apartment, arriving with a gift for her. Domino is
nowhere to be found, but he is invited in by her roommate. The two flirt with
each other but she begins to open up about Domino's whereabouts. It turns out
she got a blood test that registered her as HIV positive, or to put it more
simply, Domino had AIDS. Seeing as that virus is sexually transmitted, Bill was
nearly in a position to receive AIDS himself, and might of had Alice not called
him when she did.
Later on, Bill obtains a newspaper while trying to evade someone who seems to be following him. The paper in question refers to the death of a beauty queen. When Bill finds her body, he recognizes her as Mandy, the prostitute he saved at Ziegler's party. This in turn leads to a new development that comes when Bill receives a call telling him Ziegler wants to see him.
Ziegler is
very calm and casual when Bill arrives, offering him a drink and even inviting
him to join in a game of pool. Eventually, Ziegler gets down to business and
reveals why he really wanted to talk. It turns out he knows about everything
that Bill has been through. He was at the mansion. The question is where. Since
everyone was cloaked and masked we can't really say, but he said he was
watching Bill. The most obvious candidate is the mysterious tricorn-masked
figure who spotted Bill immediately, but I have another, slightly more
interesting theory.
The idea that
I propose is that Ziegler was in fact the Inquisitor, not just present at the
party but actually running it. He claims to have seen "everything",
which would make sense as the leader, and of all the people in this group the
leader would be the one most likely to know about its members. After all,
everybody is masked, but Ziegler seems to know their identities. As he puts it,
"I'm not going to tell you their names, but if I told you I don't think
you'd sleep so easy". It sounds as though a lot of the people are
politicians or people who otherwise would not want to be seen in this kind of
environment. Who else but the leader would know this information? Also, why would
any one member of such a secret group of people risk talking about it outside
the party without fear of consequences? Unless they were the leader and thus
had no one to answer to.
Ziegler
claims that the whole thing was staged, simply meant to scare Bill into keeping quiet. According
to him, Bill's friend was taken from his hotel but simply put on a plane to Seattle, and while Mandy was the mysterious woman who "sacrificed" herself for
Bill, that was all just for show, and her death afterwards was a mere
coincidence. Bill remains unsure of it, as these explanations make sense. Nick
never actually saw anything, so it's not like he would be able to tell anyone
about what happened, and it was already established that Mandy was hooked on
drugs. On the other hand, from what we have seen, it might not be unreasonable
to assume that Ziegler just wants to put Bill's mind at ease and cover up what
really happened.
That evening,
Bill returns home to find Alice sleeping, with the mask next to her. The
obvious assumption is that Alice found the mask and put on Bill's pillow as a
way of confronting him, but in a Stanley Kubrick film you should never take
anything at face value. If you pay attention, the mask is never actually
touched by any of the characters during the scene, and it may not actually be
there. For one thing Alice doesn't seem the kind of person who would be
comfortable sleeping next to a mask like that. The mask here is used more as a
symbol of Bill's guilt over his actions during the film, and how it will haunt
him for the rest of his life. Seeing this reminder finally causes him to break
down and confess to Alice.
In the
following scene, Bill has told Alice everything that happened to him, possibly
even including the weird sex party he attended. Once he has opened up, it allows
them to finally reconcile. Their marriage seems to be back on track, and the
film ends on an optimistic note, but this is hardly a "happily ever
after" situation. Bill and Alice may have gotten through this situation,
but that is not the end of the road for them. It's very likely that they will
have other problems in the future, ones that will force them once again to
question whether they truly love each other.
In the end,
love was never a driving force behind anything. Everyone in Eyes Wide Shut is driven
purely by sexual urges, just as it is in all of us. Apart from Helena, there was not a single
character in the film that was not sexually active, male or female. Almost every
single person was driven by a desire for some sort of sexual experience, with
the only thing that changed being how they got it. Emotions had nothing to do
with it. Everyone is driven by a biological desire for sexual interaction, and
ultimately it seems that there is no such thing as true undying love.
Very cynical, indeed. Don't remember enough about this movie to comment on if I think it supports your views or not. I've only seen it once years ago and didn't really enjoy it despite all the nudity. It's probably time for a rewatch as I'm a much different viewer now than I was then.
ReplyDeleteIt's definitely a film that requires you to be in a certain mindset, and considering it's almost three hours it does require a bit of patience, but if you can manage that you should be fine. I remember you mentioned not being a fan of 2001, but if you enjoyed any of Kubrick's other films you should be okay.
DeleteI enjoy plenty of his work...just not 2001. Run time is no issue as long as the material warrants it. I'm guessing I just didn't "get it" first time I saw EWS. We'll see if that's changed.
DeleteWell, since it's technically a Christmas movie this would be a good time to watch it. I'll have to keep an eye out for that review, it should be interesting to hear what you have to say on it.
DeleteDifferent choice for a Christmas film:) I agree with you about all the TV shlock out there (Jenny McCarthy in Santa baby comes to mind and I am thankful for never having seen it). I have not seen Eyes Wide Shut yet because I was fearful of having to see Tom Cruise naked. I think Kubrick found the dark side of nature, especially sex, intriguing. It is hinted at in The Shining. The furry going down on a "respectable" guest. People even get turned on with defecation and peeing which, to me, is gross but they are out there. I have not yet been in the right mind set to see this yet but I think I will wait until after Christmas. I have to watch White Christmas this year still and be grossed out by how thin Vera Ellen is. Your presentation of Eyes Wide Shut has made me more interested in seeing the film
ReplyDeleteWell, it's good to know I've gotten someone's attention with this movie.
Delete