This week, the theme for Wanderer's Thursday Movie Picks Meme is adaptations of classic literature. I've got some experience in this area so this one should be pretty straight forward. I did use to read (abridged versions of) classic novels when I was younger, yet another way I wasn't like others in my class. I think there was even a period where I actually wanted to go into politics and outlaw any form of modern literature because I didn't like the fact that nobody else could see what I was seeing in these books. There is just one catch, which is that I can't do poems or plays. Fortunately, poetry is probably my weakest subject when it comes to literature, and the only classic playwright I really know all that well is Shakespeare, so this isn't all that much of a problem.
Now there might be some dispute over what precisely can be considered "classic". I've gotten into a few debates myself over whether Lovecraft counts as "classic literature" or not (for the record, he does), but when people think of classic literature, they often imagine authors such as Jane Austen or Leo Tolstoy. Not very many people would think of science fiction, but there are several classic authors who were known for their contributions to the genre. Since I imagine this will be the less obvious route, let's look at three adaptations of classic science fiction stories by one of its founding authors, Jules Verne.
A Trip to the Moon (1902)
How could we discuss adaptations of classic literature and omit one of the earliest examples? Georges Méliès famous A Trip to the Moon is actually a combination of two early science fiction novels: Verne's From Earth to the Moon and H.G. Wells' The First Men in the Moon. From Verne's novel it borrows the idea of travelling to the moon in a giant canon, while its vision of the Lunar surface (particularly the presence of "Selenites") more closely resembles Wells' vision. Méliès' film is often considered historically significant for several reasons, most notably for being one of the earliest known films to tell a story (even if the "story" is little more than an excuse to show off his then-revolutionary special effects) and one of the first science fiction movies.
20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954)
This 1954 adaptation of the Jules Verne classic is one I'd not only call one of Walt Disney's finest achievements, but in general one of my all-time favorite films. It is very unusual for Disney, being a family film at its core but also not being afraid to go into more adult territory when it needs to. Most Disney films have a clearly defined hero and villain, but here there is a greater moral ambiguity not normally seen in their work (the conflict occurs between four men, but all of them have understandable motives, goals, and feelings, so in a way they are all relatable if for different reasons). It also contains some incredible underwater cinematography, spectacular model work, and Kirk Douglas singing! What's not to love?
Journey to the Center of the Earth (1959)
There have been a few attempts to adapt Jules Verne's famous novel about a scientific expedition to uncover the mysteries of the Earth's core, but this version was the first and it is definitely the best. Of course, that's not saying much considering that this is the only adaptation of the book that is actually a good movie in its own right (don't even get me started on that atrocious 3-D interpretation back in 2008, and as if that weren't bad enough the filmmakers had to go and make a sequel butchering another Verne classic, The Mysterious Island). Once again, James Mason returns to lead an expedition into the unknown with three companions (and a duck). There are some changes made, most notably the presence of a villain and an added female lead (though for once it actually works, probably because they actually gave her character depth and strength instead of just trying to force in a romance), but it is probably the closest anyone has ever come to capturing the essence of Verne's original vision.
Great picks! All three movies are on my watch list, hopefully I'll get around to watching them.
ReplyDeleteJames Mason has got one the most awesome voices in the entire history of industry. Anyway...I've only actually seen A Trip to the Moon. Nothing wrong with a slice of movie history. Been meaning to see 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea for a while but never got round to it.
ReplyDeleteA Trip to the Moon is one of my all-time favorites! So perfectly done. Those special effects still hold up, in their way. 20,000 Leagues I haven't seen in years, but I remember loving it as a kid. I don't think I've ever seen this version of Journey to the Center of the Earth, though.
ReplyDeleteNice! I haven't seen any of these, but I've heard of them. Eventually I should get around to it.
ReplyDelete20,000 Leagues Under the Sea is such a great film! Love that you highlight that here. I really want to see some of Melles films, badly!
ReplyDeleteGreat choices! I didn't even consider H.G. Wells and Jules Verne.
ReplyDelete1902! Wow, you went BACK! Haven't seen that one. Haven't seen the '59 version of Journey to the Center of the Earth, either. Been meaning to on that one. I did see the '08 version and, um, the less said about that the better. I've read and seen the movie for 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea. Liked the book, and the movie was okay, but dragged on too long.
ReplyDeleteLove that you did a theme within the theme! I haven't seen A Trip to the Moon but have always been curious. 20,000 Leagues is such a fun film and you can't beat Kirk Douglas giving his movie star best and James Mason and that silky voice of his. I'm a little less fond of Journey to the Center of the Earth though again happy for the inclusion of Mason but Pat Boone...well not so much. They both do well at serving the material.
ReplyDeleteLove all 3 of your picks. I love Melies and thought he was quite ahead of his time. JourneyTo The Centre of the Earth is one of my all time favourite-love Gertrude
ReplyDeleteClassic picks, man! Truly.
ReplyDelete