Monday, 3 November 2014

Thursday Movie Picks Meme: Movies Featuring Amnesiacs


This week, the theme for Wanderer's Thursday Movie Picks Meme is amnesia. The idea of an individual somehow losing their memories, whether due to injury, illness, psychological trauma, or some other factor and the subsequent confusion and disorientation that comes with it can be an interesting subject to explore in a narrative. It can be very effective in establishing mystery as the protagonist struggles to piece together who they are or what's been happening up to this point. Lots of films have covered this and taken it in very different directions.

I have to pick three and two were easy, the third was harder to select because I didn't want to pick one that was too obvious and the only other possible candidate I could find was one I was reluctant to use because explaining the amnesic aspect of the story would ruin the twist ending of a great horror film. Still, I think the one I do have should work.

Dark City (1998)


An unusual case in that the amnesia in the hero comes not so much from losing his memories as it does from never having them in the first place (it's complicated). This guy wakes up in the middle of some dingy bizarre city knowing almost nothing beyond the fact that he is apparently married and has a mysterious desire to get to some place called "Shell Beach" which he can never seem to find. The other strange thing is that he has a few bizarre superhuman powers, and also no idea how he got them. This ends up being a crucial part of the story, as his inability to conform allows him to notice some really strange things about the world he lives in that other people do not.

Memento (2000)


This is a slight variation on the concept of "amnesia" since the main character technically can remember who he is and most of his life, but only up to the point where he was attacked and suffered brain damage that impeded his ability to retain any memories created after. He actually does have a pretty effective system to keep himself organized which includes writing himself notes that remind him what he needs to do and always keeping a camera on hand to help him keep track of people he meets and places of immediate significance. It seems to work quite well, perhaps a little too well as we find out at the end.

Mulholland Drive (2001)

In possibly one of Lynch's best movies, a woman loses her memory after finding herself the lone survivor of a car accident and wanders into the life of an aspiring actress. She doesn't even know her own name (she adopts the nickname "Rita" after seeing a poster for Rita Hayworth). The only thing she can remember is that the accident had some sort of connection to something happening on Mulholland Drive. This is also an interesting case in that unlike a lot of movies about the subject of amnesia we never get any straight answers. We see fragments of things that might have happened but in the end precisely how the events of the film came about is for the viewer to work out.

8 comments:

  1. memento is a superb film and dark City is excellent. I have not seen the last film but i do enjoy these types of films. There was a recent film with Liam Neeson and, although not on par with the ones you speak here, it is quite good...just can't quite recall the name

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, you're thinking of Unknown. That did sound interesting but I never actually saw it. Mulholland Drive is a memorable experience, although it can get a bit weird.

      Delete
  2. Did Birgit just drop the best amnesia joke, or am I reading too much into her comment? Anyhoo, I love Memento and Dark City and was leaning heavily toward picking them myself. Nice work, John.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. Dark City wasn't one I was originally planning. I just had some trouble finding another film that worked. The only other one I could get was Angel Heart, and I couldn't explain the amnesic aspect of the story without giving away the twist ending.

      Delete
    2. OMG-I did a funny and didn't know it:) maybe I need to get checked into some clinic:)

      Delete
  3. I haven't seen any of the movies you've mentioned, but Memento is my blind spot choice for December, and Mulholland Drive being in my preliminary list for next year. Dark City sounds interesting, putting it on my watch list!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Both are very good choices. Memento might be a bit disorienting at first due to its non-linear structure, but that does add to the experience of the protagonist and of course it all builds up a dark twist ending that technically happens at the halfway point (it's complicated).

      Mulholland Drive is also a very interesting experience, though it can be a bit confusing as well. I've seen it at least four or five times now and I've only just been starting to get an idea of what the heck its deal is.

      Delete
  4. It's been super long since I've seen Memento...definitely want to rewatch it.
    Wandering through the Shelves

    ReplyDelete